The Road to
Poverty is a Rich One
My rewarding summer
in Peru
By Jennifer
Klein '01
In May 2001, as
I crossed the stage in Daniel-Meyer Coliseum, my
parents prayed that their Horned Frog would finally
be on a path toward happiness and financial
stability. They're still pondering the stability
part, as I seem to have landed on an international
road to poverty.
A semester at
TCU's London Centre led after graduation to Mexico,
Japan, Georgetown University's School of Foreign
Service and, last summer, the highland city of
Abancay, Peru, in the Andes Mountains. The handful
of other foreigners caught in this remote outpost
were either sent by God or the United Nations. I was
in the latter cohort, assigned to Abancay as the
only summer graduate student intern for the United
Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF) in Peru.
My UNICEF work
took me from Abancay up to an oxygen-deprived 11,000
feet, where nine indigenous communities had one
phone, one shower and four flushing toilets. Since
some of the communities did not have roads, I was
forced to do something few Texans ever do: I walked.
And as I tottered precariously across the crumbling
face of an Andean landslide, I couldn't help but
look 10,000 feet below and think, "So this is why
UNICEF made me buy life insurance."
Officially, my
job was to design and test an information-gathering
system that Peruvian officials could use to evaluate
the educational network in the indigenous
communities, to find out if their policies were
working. Most days I sat down with local teachers,
parents, community leaders and children and chatted
about their schools. I typically found myself living
as the teachers do — sleeping in the schools,
working by candlelight with no electricity and
bathing when I returned to civilization in Abancay.
Between
interviews and travels elsewhere in Peru, I took
pictures. I wanted to show that richness and beauty
flower amid the poverty. That even when women are
denied an education and treated as property, they
possess amazing strength and kindness. That in
children's eyes, hope abounds.
I now know that
the key to reducing world poverty is empowerment,
not pity. Opportunity, not charity. I believe that
improving education in other countries will empower
the impoverished and give them the opportunities
they crave for economic prosperity.
"Forgotten
and Forlorn" Abancay
I was tempted
to give some guidance every time I saw another
foreigner on the streets of Abancay — Hey, Machu
Picchu's 10 hours that way. With a guidebook
describing Abancay (left) as a "forgotten" and
"forlorn" stopover on the death bus between Cuzco
and Lima, any foreigner walking the streets must be
lost. But living on the set of a History Channel
documentary on the Andean highlands did have a few
perks: I had a room with a view, the most expensive
meal in town was $3, and when asked if they've heard
of McDonald's, residents affirmed that the chain has
not spread heart attacks and Happy Meals to every
forgotten corner of the globe. McDonald's? Isn't
that a restaurant in Lima?
Claudia
Claudia manages
a tiny store in a dirt hut while watching over her
five children. In traditional communities, women are
seldom asked to share their opinions, and many local
mothers shied from my interview questions. Claudia
calmly shared her hope for her children's future
through education but still expressed resentment for
the teachers, whom she believes do not understand
the community and indigenous way of life. "They
sleep when they are supposed to be teaching, and
some days they don't come to school until 10 a.m.,
if they come at all," she said.
Since teachers
in isolated indigenous communities have no outside
supervision and face extremely difficult living
conditions, they often have little motivation to
stay or excel. They are known as "Tuesday/Wednesday
teachers" because some only teach two or three days
a week. Motivating and monitoring teachers is a
struggle for governments in developing countries
that strive to provide an equal, quality education
for all children.
One successful
solution is to empower mothers like Claudia to
participate, and informally supervise schools to
ensure that the cycle of educational inopportunity
and social exclusion ends.
No Car and
Out of Gas
After a long
day hiking to the top of the Andes, the UNICEF
education consultant and I were out of gas. Our next
stop was 2.5 hours down the mountain, and throwing
ourselves off the cliff, hoping we'd land in a
community below, was looking more appealing. While I
was interviewing parents, the consultant struck a
deal with a local woman: $6 for her horse to take
our packs down the mountain. "Too much!" the woman
said, insisting that we pay half our suggested
price. In most places, locals think "foreigner" and
"millionaire" are synonymous, and they have no
problem redistributing the wealth through
overcharging the unsuspecting.
Maybe this was
a sign that mankind is innately benevolent when
seeing another human being in need. Whatever her
rationale, our blessed savior, wearing shoes made of
tire rubber, and her faithful steed beat us down the
mountain by 20 minutes.
A Safe Place
for Children
I began my
interview with the 11 students of the tiny
elementary school with an icebreaker. "Do you like
your teacher?" For the first time in all of my
interviews, the students answered almost in unison:
"NO." Why? "Because he beats us." Startled, I tried
to clarify: "But, why does he beat you?" "Because we
don't learn."
The parents
later confirmed that they could hear screaming
coming from the school. Still, things were better
now than in the past. The teacher only taught one
week per month before the 2005 school year, and
having a teacher who beats the children is better
than no teacher at all.
The teacher
defended himself when I talked with him, saying that
the children were being abused in their homes and
never wanted to leave the safety of the school. He
may not have been lying. There is no safe place for
some of these children — school or home — as long as
parents, teachers and community members do not
understand that children have rights.
Accessorize
While in the
middle of nowhere in Peru, my mom called and kindly
offered, "Jennuh-fur, do yew wont uh rahhnestone
belt? They're awl thuh rage in North Texas!" I was
spending my days with women wearing their only
clothing. Their accessories were a man's hat with an
artificial flower, peacock feather or satin ribbon,
which designated their home community, or a backpack
for carrying the youngest of their two to 13
children.
Grand
Champion Llamas, Deep Fried Guinea Pig and
Indigenous Spectator Sports
I went to Cuzco
expecting to see the city and visit Machu Picchu. I
ended up at the Peruvian version of the State Fair
of Texas. I snapped photos of the grand champion
llamas and alpacas, enjoyed a bit of llama herding
and gawked at the teepee-shaped mountains of fried
guinea pigs, a traditional Peruvian dish.
Stocks,
Bonds and Education
For many
Peruvian parents, discussing education is like a
visit to your investment banker. "Hi, Mr. and Mrs.
Hugo Chavez, I hear you're considering making an
investment in little Shakira here. If you keep her
out of the fields for a few years and put her in
school, you'll get a great return on your
investment. She'll be educated. She'll make more
money for the family in the future."
In the U.S.,
the government has already discussed the investment
in education and made the decision: Children must be
in school until they're 16. The same type of law
exists in Peru, stating that all children will have
nine years of education, but no one has the capacity
to enforce it. And authorities know that for some
families, enforcement might mean starvation.
Children must work to support their families. If
they can, families usually will invest in their
sons. This beautiful girl in the photo will be lucky
if she can read the card in front of her; in 2006
nearly 100 million girls and boys throughout the
world will suffer the same fate.
Plagued by the
travel bug following two semesters at the TCU London Centre,
Jennifer Klein '01 has been globetrotting. She taught high
school and university-level English in Toluca, Mexico, then
elementary and junior high school English in Nagaoka, Japan.
In May 2006 she will graduate with a master of science
degree in foreign service from Georgetown University, with a
concentration in international development and certification
in refugees and humanitarian emergencies. After graduation,
she hopes to continue following "the road to poverty" with
Save the Children or UNICEF.
Comment at
tcumagazine@tcu.edu
|